This map is from a 1990's European Road Map and provides a modern look of
the Holtzwihr, France area and the forested area just north where Audie Murphy
made his famous Medal of Honor stand against the Germans. On the map,
you will notice a faint red "x" along the small road travelling north to
south through the wooded area into the town of Holzwihr. This is the spot
where the ditched and burning M10 tank destroyer was located and where Audie
Murphy climbed aboard to beat off the attacking Nazi infantry and tank
units.
You should note that this woodline has grown in a southerly direction since
the battle. On January 26, 1945 the southern edge of the woodline was much
closer to the M10 tank destroyer. The town of Holtzwihr has also grown
much closer to the woodline. The northerly extention of buildings was not
there in 1945.
The following narrative are excerpts from different accounts written by
Marty Black, an American Airlines employee, who has made several trips to
Holtzwihr, France. Marty, an avid military historian, has rediscovered the
M10 Tank Destroyer's location. His account is very interesting.
Holtzwihr Trip Report, 14 Aug '96 or "Still Crazy After All These Years"
[American Airline] Crew Schedules called on 12 Aug and offered me my choice of
4 trips to fly the next day. Four trips! That's never happened before!
But I had a somewhat tough time deciding what to take: London, ... Brussels,
San Juan, ... [or ]Zurich, yes! I was just there last week and did my pre-
battlefield "recon," checking out the rental car locations, buying a good
map of the city, marking the route between the hotel and the airport, etc. I
had been wanting to drive from Zurich to the ethnic-German region of Alsace
in eastern France, to search the spot near Holtzwihr where Audie Murphy earned
the CMOH on 26 Jan 1945. The fall and winter weather is just around the corner,
and since it has been rumored all year that [American Airlines] will pull out
of Zurich this winter, I decided that this would be the trip, rain or shine!
The weather forecast was for rain, but I hadn't been metal detecting since my
last trip to Huertgen Forest in October 1995, and I needed a "fix."
Left Chicago at 1640 and landed at Zurich at 0800 (0100 Chicago time.) Enroute,
the two copilots and all 10 Flight Attendants thought my plans for the layover
were very ambitious and interesting, but no one was crazy enough to come along.
Got an Alamo mini-Opel at the airport. A 20% discount for all AAL employees,
only about $20, unlimited mileage. What a deal! But then there is insurance
for $38, and taxes, and it came to about $60. Not such a good deal. (Later
that day, when I filled the gas tank, it came to $28! About $4 a gallon,
but I got great gas mileage.) A total of $88 for about 12 hours of useage.
Went to the hotel, changed clothes, and hit the road at 0930 (0230 Chicago
time.) It was drizzling, with spots of rain, but I was confident it would
be an OK-day, as long as I didn't have to painfully squit through windshield
wipers with bloodshot eyes. I was pleasantly surprised how easy a ride it
was; I was a bit nervous about having to negotiate the low hills of the Alps
while fatigued, but later had noticed on a relief map that there is a natural
pass all the way from Zurich NW to Alsace. We had a few large hills enroute,
but rather than drive over them, I drove through them in large modern
concrete tunnels, a few of which seemed to be a mile or two long. It was
"autobahn"-type driving most of the way, with speeds about 85-90 mph. I was
told that continental Europe has had more rain this summer than usual, with
mild temperatures, and the various shades of green were breath-taking. The
scenes looked like those from a postcard of Switzerland.
Came abreat Colmar after about a 2 hour drive, and I knew I needed to leave
the highway and go east into the "sticks," toward the Rhine, to get to the
small town of Holtzwihr. I apparently misread the road number on the sign
that I needed, but it said "Freiburg." That's ... in Germany, and I didn't
want to go there, but that was roughly, very roughly, in the direction I
needed to head ... So I had to proceed further north and get off at the
next exit, road D3. This was fortuitous, because I ended up coming in to
Holtzwihr on the same tiny, winding farm track (un-numbered) that Murphy's
unit apparently used as they attacked in a southerly direction. I had
[a friend's] photo of the site, taken in 1973, and I was looking for a soccer
goal to mark the field. The Germans successfully counterattacked from the
village across the open area and whipped the GIs. That's when Murphy
rallied and single-handedly stopped the counterattack, with carbine and then
.50 cal [machine gun] fire from an abandoned burning Tank Destroyer, while
continuing to call in artillery fire using a field telephone.
Sure enough, a soccer goal came into view, but it was on the wrong side of
the road! And the lay of the land was wrong; the whole perspective was
screwy. This sports area was right up against the edge of town, and the
open area was missing. I got out and walked around, trying to make sense
of it. A sign on a building said "Football Club Holtzwihr" (that's what
they call soccer in Europe), but the location definitely wasn't the same in
[my friend's] photo.
I then drove around town, trying the roads that lead into town from the west
and east, but no luck. There was apparently only one soccer field complex
in Holtzwihr. I spotted a group of young men outside a restaurant/pub and
asked them if anyone spoke English. Nope, so I showed them [my friend's]
photo and asked them in German where it was. They gave me very detailed
directions right back to the soccer field I had been to!
I then remembered that Murphy's CMOH citation read "near Holtzwihr." Maybe
the action took place near the neighboring town of Riedwihr, just to the NE.
I drove there, but no luck finding a soccer field. However, alongside the
main two-lane road (D45) there were several square concrete blockhouses, but
they didn't appear to have any firing apertures. Just two doors, on opposite
sides of each blockhouse. They had the right-angle blast entrances, so I
figured they were WWII vintage, but only one appeared to have been blown up.
Perhaps there was a German airstrip there during the war, and these building
[were built for] storage of ordnance, etc. I was tempted to linger there and
explore some more, but I was on a "mission" and was getting a bit anxious that,
although I had managed to find this small town, I'd driven around it for over
an hour, and couldn't find the site. What would [my friend] say when I told
him I couldn't find it? What would the crew say when I came back empty-handed?
Went back into Holtzwihr and asked a lady standing on a corner. Got the
identical directions back to the Football Club! Spotted a Bibliotek (library)
and leaped out of the car, figuring there would be someone who spoke better
English (better than I spoke German), and perhaps the Murphy site was well
known! No luck, the sign on the door said they were open only from 1800-1900.
I was getting mighty discouraged and angry for having gone to such expense
and trouble, and I was getting really tired, but decided to check out the
small hamlet of Wickerschwir just to the east of Holtzwihr on D4. Going
around a traffic circle, I saw a maintenance man doing some landscaping inside
the circle, and our eyes met. Seeing no one in the rearview mirror, I stopped
right there in the road, and asked if he spoke English. Nope, but did I
speak German? Not well - here we go again ... And Again, he gave me precise
directions back to the soccer field.
Exasperated, I tried to explain to him that I wanted to match up [my friend's]
photo, and "der alte Baum" (the old tree). He then indicated that he knew
exactly what I meant, and offered to "zeigen" (show) me. What a lucky break!
He got in an old truck that looked like something the Germans used in WWII;
a corrugated steel body. I followed and we drove back to the soccer field,
but then he motioned that we were to continue north up that farm track into
the woods. We went an additional 150 yards or so, until we were surrounded
by trees and he stopped!
I got out of the car, wondering why we had stopped here, when I noticed that
he wasn't alone; there was another guy in the truck. As they approached me,
I had - for a fleeting moment - the thought that I was about to lose my
wallet and the approximately $100 in French and Swiss francs that I had for
emergencies. I wasn't afraid for my safety, but wondered how I would manage
to drive back over two hours without any money for gas, credit cards, ID, etc.
The natives remained friendly, however, and the driver showed me that the
soccer field in [my friend's] photo had been converted into a "community
forest" and that the old tree had been gone for some time. Sure enough, it
was suddenly obvious that a large rectangular area was planted with the same
type tree, all the same size (age), and with typical German efficiency, they
had been planted in closely-spaced, straight rows. In Winston's photo, the
dark farmer's field between the old tree and the town is a cornfield, and the
stalks rose to over 6 feet, obscuring all but the very tops of some of the
buildings, blocking a "then and now" comparison.
I thanked the two fellows, and opened up my hockey bag of jungle boots, flight
suit, hat, gloves, garden "digger," etc. Swept [with a metal detector]the
ditch on the west side of the road, but it was a tangle of brambles and other
undergrowth. Went into the woods on that side of the road, and found lots of
shellholes, shrapnel, and a REM-UMC .45 ACP cartridge.
Crossed the road to the side that I was really interested in (east), hoping
to find a carbine casing or .50 cal casing, "evidence" that I had indeed
found Murphy's exact location. But I noticed that others had been metal-detecting
there also. There were small piles of old farm tools and other junk in the
area. Soda cans and tin foil also. As I worked my way back to the north (from
where the GIs came, and to where they retreated), I came upon a large depression
about 10-12 feet from the road that could have been Murphy's CP. I then got
a bit excited to find a fairly large amount of WWII field telephone wire.
(When Murphy's unit was about to be over-run, he ordered his radio operator
to the rear so it wouldn't be captured. He then used his field telephone to
call for artillery.) A healthy tree had grown right on top of the wire, but
I managed to pull a couple of feet out the ground. In this area there were
several 30-06 casings and complete rounds. DM4 (AP), LC4 (AP), RA 43 (maybe
a tracer) and SL 42 (ball). Also found a damaged GI buckle, most probably
from a M1936 Musette Bag. These were occassionally carried by officers, but
can most often be seen hanging on the sides of Tanks and Tank Destroyers in
WWII photos. (Paratroopers also used these as backpacks, but Holtzwihr wasn't
an "airborne" battle.)
Moving further to the north (rear), there was another depression very close
to the first one, and this one was surrounded by 30-06 casings, but no clips.
Maybe from the (cotton belt-fed) machine gun that Murphy describes in his
book?! I even found what may be a battered charging handle for a M1919
[machine gun], but it could also be a mangled piece of farm machinery. I'm
not sure; Does a MG's handle have knurling on it? About 50 yards "downrange"
of this site, I found three 30-06 spent bullets very close to each other,
just under the surface of the ground. A 3-round burst? My imagination was
taking some "liberties," but at least I was awake now and having fun!
Searched around some more, but only found shrapnel, the fuze of a US
artillery round (like the ones commonly found on Okinawa) and unidentifiable
bits of iron. Curiously, I also found several modern white-plastic dummy
rounds with (fired) brass heads. They appeared to be about 7-8 mm rifle
rounds and 9mm Luger-type pistol rounds. (I'd found these in the Huertgen
Forest also, last year.)
A few huge tractors came down the road, as well as a few families on bicycles,
and a man walking a dog. But I was mostly left alone with nature and my
imagination for the afternoon. Happily, the weather was cooperating. After
leaving Switzerland and entering France, the sun began to peek through the
clouds, and the temperature was a pleasant, but humid 70-75 degrees. The
soil was full of stones and roots, but fairly easy to dig. I spotted toads,
"leaping" spiders, several huge snails (in shells) and orange slugs as big
as my thumbs! Mosquitos also, and I was damn glad I had "Cutters" in my
hockey bag. I was sweating in my flight coveralls, and my arms were getting
raw from chafing, so I peeled it down, but then the brambles and other itchy
vegetation were going right through my undershirt and the poison ivy-type
burning was driving me crazy. As I type this, I have several spider-type
bites around my waistline.
I wanted to find the Maison Rouge bridge (not on the map), which was collapsed
by one of Murphy's support tanks, but it was getting late in the afternoon.
From past (dangerous!) experience driving back late after similar excursions
in Germany and France, I wanted to be back in Zurich before it got dark. When
I left Holtzwihr at 6 pm, I had been up for over 28 hours, and it showed! And
I still had a two-hour drive back! I did fine until about 20 minutes from
Zurich, when I suddenly "came to" with a start and realized that I had drifted
off for a couple of seconds at 90 mph! Pulled into the next gas station and
got a large Swiss chocolate bar; that got me "up" for the remainder of the trip!
Got to the hotel, and found out that it cost $25 to park in their basement
garage! No way! Parking was free in the "white line" zones on the street,
from 7 pm to 7 am, but after driving around the neighborhood for ten minutes
I couldn't find one unoccupied ... So I pulled halfway up on the sidewalk on
the front driveway of the hotel, and walked into "old town" to get a (English)
beer and some food. (I had eaten only 2 granola bars and two Cokes since
breakfast on the airplane.)
Went out in the morning, and the car was still there. Drove it to the
airport, met the rest of the crew, and flew back to Chicago. The whole trip
encompassed only 48 hours. I sure wish these "battlefield opportunities"
came up more than once every 10 months, but I certainly couldn't do this every
week!
Webmaster's Note: Marty did have
the opportunity to later return to the Holtzwihr site. To read about his
other visits and to see photos of artifacts he recovered, click the Medal of
Honor Ribbon below.